The Catholic Legate

The Catholic Apologetics section of The Catholic Legate is dedicated to providing our visitors with conventional Catholic Apologetics, including biblical, theological, and historical issues surrounding the Catholic Faith. Each topic-page is divided into sub-categories: articles, dialogues, debates, and Q&A. Visitors who are interested in suggesting an article or asking a question are encouraged to e-mail us their request. Should you wish to dialogue with one of our staff on an apologetics subject, please be sure to read our Limited Confidentiality Policy beforehand.

Caesarea Philippi, The Towering Backdrop to Peter's Profession
The Catholic Legate's director, John Pacheco, had an article published in Catholic Answer's This Rock magazine on the significance of Caesarea Philippi to the papacy. John explores the historical background to the area where Jesus conferred primary authority on St. Peter, and offers a unique angle on the geographical relevance to the Catholic teaching on the Papacy. Check out the April edition of This Rock and get a new angle on the primacy of Peter!!! (Pacheco - 14KB - 05.06).

Joseph and His Brothers
In this short article, Catholic Legate Director, John Pacheco shows the biblical basis for the papacy as far back as Genesis!. (Pacheco - 6 KB - 06.12)

Where Peter is, There is the Church
Father Piotrowski provides a wonderful recap of the evidence which proves that Peter's tomb is situated directly beneath the Pope’s altar in the Vatican Basilica. (Piotrowski - 15KB - 04.09)

"This article was originally published in Love One Another Magazine (Spring, 2003 Edition), a Catholic magazine dedicated to promoting and preserving Catholic youth and family. It is a rich and wonderful magazine which appeals to the whole Catholic community. Wonderful articles affirming the culture of life are interspersed among inspiring personal testimonials as well as edifying accounts of the saints of our holy faith, not to mention solid apologetic articles like the one featured above. This magazine is simply a lightning bolt from heaven, designed to make a real effort at converting people to the Catholic faith. Paradoxically, it's both hard hitting, yet gentle. If you don't subscribe to any Catholic periodical or you only have room for only one, then get this one! You simply cannot put it down." - John Pacheco, Director, The Catholic Legate

_________________________________

Bishop Leon Dubravsky of KamenetsPodolsky, Ukraine, writes: "It is an ideal tool of evangelization (...) In my diocese in Ukraine, the Russian-language edition is of great importance in advancing the spiritual formation of our society, influencing the consciences, hearts, and ideological outlook of many. We use it as a prayer book as well as a religious knowledge resource. Its articles give us hope and strength in difficult situations. They point out and warn against dangers, and teach the people how to love God and their neighbor. Many thanks for your missionary activity. We look forward to reading future issues in the hope that they will introduce people to the Good News of Love. May the magazine become a landmark of the Universal Church in the East."

“You have no idea - writes a joyful young reader - how many people you have brought back to God. Reading your testimonies and wonderful articles, one feels that God is using your magazine to bring sinners to the real fountain of His graces”.

The Council of Chalcedon & the Papacy
Mark Bonocore discusses a shining example of how the papacy has its roots in early Christian teaching. In this article, Mark highlights the important historical evidence which shows how the Papacy preserved orthodox Christian teaching against Monophysitism. (Bonocore - 14KB - 04.05)

The Unbreakable Pinata: Honorius and the Protestant Polemic
Everybody knows that Pope Honorius has been the proverbial whipping boy for Protestant polemicists for centuries now in their quest to disprove the Catholic dogma of papal infallibility. Staff Apologist John Pacheco revisits the issue and provides a modest yet cogent elucidation of the Catholic defense of why the case against Honorius is pretty flimsy. After reading this short apologetic, you'll understand why the Pinata is still intact. (Pacheco - 24KB - 02.11)

The Monarchial Episcopate: A Merciful Response to James White's "Roman Catholic Apologists Practice Eisegesis in Scripture and Patristics"

Mark Bonocore has contributed this great series of articles on early Church governance of the hiearchy by responding to James White's recent critique of an earlier article written by Mark. A must read!

Joseph & Peter: Separate From Their Brethren
Pacheco examines the link between two prominent biblical figures with his insightful look at the complementary roles which both Joseph and Peter played in their respective patriarchal and apostolic communities. (Pacheco - 25KB - 02.04)

Was the Papacy Established by Christ?
Back in 1999, Mark Bonocore and Evangelical Jason Engwer debated whether Jesus established the Papacy. Read how Mark picks apart Jason's misconceptions and faulty arguments. [Hosted Offsite]

Inquiries from a Lutheran Minister
Mark Bonocore interacts with some questions from a Lutheran minister. All very polite and nice-like. We were on our best behaviour with this one. Youse be nice to us and we'ze be nice to you. (Bonocore - 104KB - 07.05)

The Council of Nicea and the Papacy
One of James White's disciples, calling himself "Stormtrooper", attempts to educate Mark Bonocore on historical Christianity and the Catholic Council of Nicea. As Mark clearly shows, however, he still belongs to the dark side. (Bonocore - 13KB - 05.06)

Debunking Eleven "Proofs" Against Peter's Presence in Rome
Mark Bonocore answers eleven alleged "proofs" which claim that St. Peter was not in Rome and did not lead the Church in the eternal city. Mark shows how shallow the objections are to Catholic truth. (Bonocore - 43KB - 05.06)

Keys of the Kingdom
Read this short exchange between Mark Bonocore and James White. Readers will agree that Mark locks out White time and time again. (Bonocore - 20KB - 04.12)

Answer to James White on the Papacy
James White gets his butt whooped by Catholic Apologist-extraordinaire, Mark Bonocore. Read how Mark takes James to school on what the early Church Fathers taught about petrine primacy and authority. You almost feel sorry for James White...but not quite. Fun for the whole family. (Bonocore - 54KB - 04.08)

Was Peter the First Pope?
A former Catholic thinks he has found major issues which debunk the Church's claims over unity and truth. Read how he is instructed otherwise. (Sippo - 9KB - 00.00)

Petrine Primacy Defended
Was Peter in Rome? Was Paul more important than Peter? What about Paul's rebuke of Peter? How do these and other questions affect Petrine Primacy? Find out in this exchange. (Sippo - 9B - 00.00)

The Keys of St. Peter
The following dialogue occurred over a number of weeks in July, 1999 on a Seventh Day Adventist discussion board with a gentleman named ‘Ted’. The dialogue focuses on Papal primacy and other related issues. (Pacheco - 287KB - 99.08)