Isn’t The Pill Great?

ROME, January 5, 2009 ( – The Vatican’s official newspaper has caused a media storm in the European press with an article asserting the abortifacient and carcinogenic effects of hormonal contraceptives.

The Italian edition of L’Osservatore Romano carries an article this week on a report by the International Federation of Catholic Medical Associations (FIAMC) that was created to commemorate the fortieth anniversary of the encyclical Humanae Vitae, the document by Pope Paul VI that reiterated the Catholic Church’s teaching on artificial birth control.

Pedro José María Simón Castellví, the president of FIAMC, wrote that “the means of contraception violate at least five important rights: the right to life, the right to health, the right to education, all right to information (their spread is at the expense of information on natural resources) and the right to equality between the sexes (the burden of contraception falls mostly on women).”

“Curiously”, Castelvi wrote, this information on the abortifacient effect of the Pill “does not reach the general public,” despite being well-known to researchers.

The hundred-page report, published in German, is an analysis of scientific data on the effects of the Pill and includes three hundred bibliographic citations, mostly from specialized medical journals.

The report “clearly demonstrates” that anovulant, low-dose hormonal birth control pills work not only by preventing ovulation but also by causing the death of an already existing child in the uterine wall. This embryonic person, Castellvi wrote, “even in its early days, is something other than an egg or female germ cell.” From the embryonic stage, the child grows in a  coordinated way and this development, unless prevented, “ends with its exit from the womb in nine months, ready to devour a litre of milk.”

The report also notes that the International Agency for Research of Cancer, an agency of the World Health Organization, reported in July 2005 that the oral preparations of combined estrogen-progestogens common in birth control pills are classified in a group of carcinogenic agents.

“The sad thing in all this,” Castelvi wrote, “is that if it is to regulate fertility, these are not the products required. The natural means of regulating fertility, ‘NFP’ or Natural Family Planning, are equally effective and also respect the person.”


VATICAN CITY, January 7, 2009 ( – An eminent doctor writing for the Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano has stated that hormones from the contraceptive pill are causing a significant rise in male infertility in western nations.

Pedro Jose Maria Simon Castellvi, President of the International Federation of Catholic Medical Associations (FIAMC), writes that “we have sufficient data to affirm that one of the reasons for the not insignificant rise in male infertility in the west (due to increasingly fewer sperm in men), is the environmental contamination caused by ‘the pill’.”

“We are confronted with a clear anti-ecological effect that demands further explanation from the manufacturers,” continued Castellvi, who also noted that the abortifacient and carcinogenic effects of the contraceptive pill are also well known (see LifeSiteNews coverage at

Castellvi’s statements echo similar utterances made by numerous other medical and scientific experts since 2004.  Female hormones from birth control pills, which enter the water supply through urination, are being blamed for declining sperm counts in human and animal populations, the growth of female sex organs in male fish, breast growth in young men, and early onset of puberty in young girls.

In September of last year, a scientist at the University of Montreal’s Department of Chemistry announced the discovery that Montreal’s water treatment plant was dumping estrogen products into rivers at a level 90 times the critical amount, a level far beyond the minimum for disrupting the fertility of fish.

Last week, Mexico’s Secretariat of Health issued a warning that use of the contraceptive pill during pregnancy could raise the risk of “genital ambiguity,” also known as hermaphrodism, in newborns.

“The sad thing about this is that, if we are talking about the regulation of fertility, these products are not necessary,” writes Castellvi, noting that Natural Family Planning methods, which involve abstaining from sexual intercourse during the fertile period of a woman’s monthly cycle, “are just as effective and furthermore they respect the nature of the person.”

Despite mounting evidence indicating the harmful effects of artificial hormones on the environment, the French Press Agency reported that Castellvi’s statements were “promptly dismissed by several organizations,” which claimed that female hormones are present “everywhere” and change once they are digested. 

Castellvi’s statements are supported by a report recently issued by FIAMC, which he says contains more than 300 source citations, the majority of which are from medical publications. His article appeared in the January 4th issue of L’Osservatore Romano.


VIENNA, January 8, 2009 ( – An Austrian chemist who helped spearhead the creation of the earliest contraceptive pill has expressed dismay at the severance of sexuality and reproduction made possible by widespread use of the pill, and has warned against the impending demographic disaster from plummeting birth rates.

Carl Djerassi wrote of his concern in a commentary appearing in the December issue of Austria’s Der Standard, where he described couples who regularly contracept as “wanting to enjoy their schnitzels while leaving the rest of the world to get on with it.”

Djerassi, who is a chemist, novelist, and playwright, is best known for helping create the synthetic hormone progestin norethindrone in 1951, together with Mexican Luis E. Miramontes and Hungarian George Rosenkranz.  The far more potent synthetic hormone was soon used for contraceptive purposes as it remains effective when taken orally, unlike natural female hormones.

At the time, Djerassi had said that “not in our wildest dreams” had he expected the chemical to be used for contraception.  Now, he writes, “My contribution is to help these people wake up,” referring to Austrian couples who freely contracept.

Lamenting that there is now “no connection at all between sexuality and reproduction,” Djerassi said, “This divide in Catholic Austria, a country which has on average 1.4 children per family, is now complete.  Most Austrians enjoy sexual intercourse without thereby wanting or begetting a child.”

Djerassi explained that Austria, which is now home to more seniors over 65 than children under 15, would soon enter “an impossible situation” as the lopsided population would result in a working class too small to support the needs of elderly pensioners. 

Therefore, he urged, Austrians would have to quickly adopt an immigration policy designed to counteract the effects of widespread contraception lest the population commit “national suicide.”

(To view the original article in German, go to:

One thought on “Isn’t The Pill Great?

  1. You know the funniest part is that Simon-Castellvi doesn’t claim that meat, methane, dairy, plastics and a whole lot of other modern day products DO NOT cause infertility. He’s just giving us another plausible modern day cause for infertility. But the way the blogs, networking sites and a whole lot of “experts” are running him down, I am almost convinced that the guy is right.

    There’s a HUGE pharmaceutical industry out there lobbying for every kind of medical treatment at the cost of people’s health. I won’t be surprised if these “experts” receive their funding from such heavy weights.

    As for all the feminists, well, to each her own. Only time will tell if sexual freedom really translates into freedom and well-being of any kind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Solve : *
11 ⁄ 11 =